The Carbondale Observer

News and commentary about Carbondale, Illinois and SIUC

The Illinois Policy Institute and Jackson County Transparency

with 4 comments

I noticed a story in this week’s Carbondale Times reporting that the Illinois Policy Institute had given the Jackson County website a grade of 21.2 out of 100 on transparency. The story isn’t online yet or I would link to it (I think the Times waits a week or so to put their print stories online, which is smart if you don’t want your ad revenue to collapse). I’ve noticed that the Illinois Policy Institute is getting its name into the news more frequently, so I visited their site.

If you check the Illinois Policy Institute’s FAQ page, you’ll find this:

What is the Institute’s political affiliation? 

The Illinois Policy Institute is independent and not affiliated with any political party. People often ask whether the Institute is conservative, libertarian, or whether it falls under some other political label. Labels can sometimes provide helpful shorthand to make it easier for strangers to become better acquainted, but they also can be inaccurate or miss the bigger picture.

The Illinois Policy Institute is dedicated to promoting the principles of liberty in all levels of government. While “liberty” can be interpreted in many ways and applied to many different arenas, we focus specifically on economic liberty and free market principles.

We work with anyone who supports our values on a particular issue, regardless of political or ideological affinity, including Democrats, Republicans and independents.

[Emphasis added.]

Terms like “principles of liberty” and “free market principles” sound great. I believe in liberty. And who wants to particpate in an unfree market? That’s like playing cards with a rigged deck, right?

The truth is, these terms are dog whistles to the right wing. For those unfamiliar with the term “dog whistle,” it refers to a type of political communication – a code, really – in which a message that is generic and pleasant sounding to the general public has a second, more specific meaning recognized by people in a political movement. An example: “culture of life.” Sounds good, right? But to people in the religious conservative movement, it means opposition to abortion rights.

The people at the Illinois Policy Institute aren’t interested in personal liberty as most of us understand it. They’re interested in repealing as much business regulation as possible (especially environmental regulation), lowering taxes on the rich, and putting an end to our already meager social safety net. They want to undermine your faith in government in order to accomplish these goals.

Long time readers will know that I’ve sometimes criticized some of the regulations in our city code. That’s because bad regulations discredit good regulations. If you believe in the value of good regulation, you should be an opponent of bad regulation. As others have pointed out, the right wing has a fanatical opposition to all regulation, but there is no equal and opposite zeal for regulation on the left. We don’t want regulation for regulation’s sake.

On the left, we want regulation because there is some harm we want to prevent or some virtue we want to require. If a given regulation either (1) fails to prevent the harm or require the virtue we favor, or (2) produces unintended consequences that overwhelm the gain produced, the proper left response is to repeal that regulation and (probably) replace it with a better one. It is in that spirit that I have criticized some of the regulations in city code – especially many of our zoning regulations.

I want to point out that I didn’t write this post to criticize the Carbondale Times, which I think does a great job with straight news reporting and which seems to have a generally liberal policy on its editorial page. In fact, the Times checked the Jackson County website and found it more compliant with transparency laws than the Illinois Policy Institute claims.

I wrote this post because it relates to an argument I made recently. In Wednesday’s post on the city council meeting, I decried what I see as unwarranted cynicism and pessimism toward the city government (I think I used the term “pathological paranoia”). I wrote this post to draw attention to folks like the Illinois Policy Institute who want to nurture and feed that suspicion so they can achieve their larger policy goals.

That’s really the point I was getting at in Wednesday’s post, though I may have made the point imperfectly. It’s good to be skeptical, but it is not helpful when otherwise liberal people – the folks who should be pushing for positive change – become so cynical and pessimistic toward their governments that they begin to resist any and all change. A solid majority of Carbondale’s citizens have a basically progressive disposition. We should lead with that part of ourselves and try to temper our cynicism so we can make the changes that will build a better community.

Now that I’ve burned through over 600 words, I’ll briefly address the substance of the article: Jackson County’s webpage. I’ve watched the Jackson County website go through several versions over the years. The current site seems inferior to the one it replaced – at least to me. The previous site was more intuitive and seemed to have more information. I don’t know if it violates our transparency laws, but it doesn’t seem like a great site to me.

Comments are welcome.


Written by The Carbondale Observer

October 11, 2012 at 7:45 am

Posted in Jackson County

Tagged with

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Thanks for the informative write up



    October 11, 2012 at 8:49 am

    • I am curious to know what the Carbondale Times found that I didn’t. Also, I’m curious to know why Jackson County didn’t reach out to me about any errors despite us contacting them. We will always revise our scores if provided new information that can be found on the website.

      In regards to the state laws that Jackson County is violating, they are currently violating FOIA and OMA laws . I cannot find the agendas being posted on their website prior to meetings, and they do not have the full website posting requirements under the Freedom of Information Act.

      Also, if they have passed a budget yet this year they have website posting requirements under IMRF laws for salaries and benefits of employees making $75K+ in total compensation.

      A list of Illinois Website Transparency Laws can be found here.

      Brian Costin

      October 11, 2012 at 10:01 am

      • Brian Costin – Thanks for the comment! I wondered if someone from the Illinois Policy Institute would respond to this. That’s one thing I admire about the right – its activists are organized and motivated to defend their ideas. Obviously I don’t agree with those ideas, but I admire the passion, skills, and organization on the right.

        The Times article should be online in a week or so, but here’s a quote for you: “A check Tuesday of Jackson County’s website showed several months of County Board meeting minutes posted and a description that the board meets at 6:00 p.m. the second Wednesday of each month. A calendar detailing county board meetings, however, runs only a month at a time.” No mention of agendas or FOIA requirements.

        I’m not sure why Jackson County officials didn’t call you back. It might be that the responsible person never received the message. It might also be that they took a look at the Illinois Policy Institute website and realized they were dealing with ideological opponents of government and nothing was to be gained by calling back. Or they might have decided that their role is to govern on behalf of their constituents, not to respond to inquiries from outside activist groups. Of course, I’m just speculating.

        Thanks again for the comment!

        The Carbondale Observer

        October 11, 2012 at 11:50 pm

    • Thanks Sandy!

      The Carbondale Observer

      October 11, 2012 at 11:42 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: